Workification

Abstract

More and more, the law is transforming activities once considered outside the market into “work.” This phenomenon, which I term “workification,” is exhibited by two case studies of graduate students who perform work in universities as part of study and of individuals who perform work for the Salvation Army and similar organizations as part of a rehabilitative program. University students, Salvation Army rehabilitants, and others historically considered nonworkers are pursuing the legal status of “employee,” seeking legal protections such as minimum wage, collective bargaining, and other workplace rights. These employee claims typically involve labor exchanges outside the traditional labor market and relationships that are not primarily understood as work ones, or what was once considered nonmarket labor. This Article identifies and examines the dual aspects of this trend: the socio-legal process by which nonmarket labor becomes work through employee classification adjudications and the broader political project of using work law to solve problems within nonmarket labor.

Drawing on a novel empirical dataset, this Article conducts the fi rst comprehensive analysis of employee classification cases under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) and Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) involving school and rehabilitation programs. Doctrinally, these cases advance a new frontier in employee classification beyond the well-studied employee/independent contractor distinction, raising fundamental questions about what constitutes work. This Article further identifies three doctrinal approaches in case law to classify nonmarket labor that respectively scrutinize the character of the institution, the entire relationship, and the labor exchange dimension therein. Sociologically, this Article uses the ongoing transformation of graduate student assistants’ roles to demonstrate how the employee classification also engenders a transformation in these social relationships, often by incentivizing parties to more clearly separate the market-value-generating labor components from the educational or rehabilitative components. In a political economic context, the workification process reacts to and further reinforces the commodification of supposedly nonmarket relationships such as education. I conclude by using the examples of nonmarket labor to reflect on work law’s limitation in containing the commodification of labor.

About the Author

Assistant Professor of Labor and Employment Law, Cornell University Industrial and Labor Relations School; Associated Faculty Member, Cornell Law School.

I thank Paulo Barrozo, Dena Bauman, Yun-chien Chang, Angela Cornell, Deborah Dinner, Afroditi Giovanopoulou, Hiba Hafiz, Jacob Hamburger, Brian Highsmith, Duncan Kennedy, Rama Hyeweon Kim, Neha Lall, Carolyn Young Larmore, Risa Lieberwitz, Robin Morgan, Gali Racabi, Kerry Rittich, César F. Rosado-Marzán, Naomi Schoenbaum, E.T. Stone, Chantal Thomas, Noah Zatz, and participants at the 19th Annual Colloquium on Scholarship in Employment and Labor Law (COSELL), 2024 Cornell Work Law Junior Scholars Workshop, Cornell Law School Faculty Workshop, Law and Society Association Annual Meeting 2025, Jurisprudence of Distribution Workshop, University of Iowa College of Law’s Law and Political Economy Seminar, and University of Toronto Faculty of Law’s Critical Analysis of Law Workshop, for their comments and suggestions.

I thank Matt Bruenig for developing and giving me early access to the database, “NLRB Research,” which enables in-depth doctrinal research of NLRB decisions.

Deepest gratitude to my student research assistants, Cass Christian, Robert Farbman, Courtney Yunyee Huang, and Anvita Kodali, for their wonderful research work on this project. Without their work, this project would not be possible.

By LRIRE