Climate Injustice, Off the Books

Abstract

Government agencies need greenhouse gas accounting—inventories that track emissions over time—to design and implement climate policies. While virtually every law and policy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions must account for those emissions in the first place, accounting itself has largely escaped public scrutiny, relegated to the margins while mitigation measures take center stage.

Policymakers and the public often mistakenly assume that greenhouse gas accounting is an inconsequential, passive bookkeeping activity. It is not: Gaps in accounting adversely affect disadvantaged communities, primarily poor communities of color. Many governments systematically exclude certain greenhouse gas emissions from their inventories, which reduces the incentives to decrease emissions from those excluded sources. These emissions omissions undercut efforts to slow climate change, a global problem which disproportionately impacts those most vulnerable. At the same time, because these excluded sources also often emit co-pollutants that worsen air quality for nearby communities and exacerbate health burdens, disincentivizing greenhouse gas emissions reductions also forgoes an opportunity to reduce local air pollution. This Article draws on original empirical analyses to demonstrate how these exclusions perpetuate environmental injustices. It highlights how maritime ports—whose emissions are often unaccounted for by governments—are overwhelmingly located near disadvantaged communities, compounding environmental and health risks.

Greenhouse gas accounting is anything but neutral. It is a powerful instrument that can either exacerbate environmental disparities or drive meaningful change. As this Article argues, recognizing the equity implications of greenhouse gas accounting is a pivotal yet underutilized strategy for environmental justice. So long as governments undercount their emissions, climate policy will remain incomplete, and the burdens of environmental harms will continue to fall disproportionately on those least responsible and most vulnerable to their devastating impacts.

About the Author

Assistant Professor of Law and Gearns & Russo Faculty Fellow of Environmental Law, Cornell Law School. I thank Dena Adler, Chinonso Anozie, William Boyd, Vanessa Casado Pérez, Allison Chatrchyan, Angela Cornell, Caroline Cox, Robin Craig, Deborah Dinner, Mike Dorf, Jessica Eaglin, Monika Ehrman, Paolo Farah, Maggie Gardner, Alison Gocke, Andrew Hammond, Colleen Honigsberg, Rob B. Jackson, Hajin Kim, Alexandra Lahav, Lisa Larrimore Ouellette, Albert Lin, Martin Lockman, Doreen Lustig, Josh Macey, Katharine Mach, Anna Mance, Chan Tov McNamarah, Gabriela Nagle Alverio, Mark Nevitt, Dave Owen, Mike Pappas, Jeff Rachlinski, Sabeel Rahman, Jonathan Skinner- Thompson, Ben Sobel, Amy Stein, Jed Stiglitz, Buzz Thompson, Kristen Underhill, Dan Walters, Gina Warren, Michelle Wilde Anderson, Katrina Wyman, and participants in the Colorado–UCLA Law Environmental Law Workshop, the Early Environmental Law Scholars Workshop at Pace Haub School of Law, the NYU Environment and Energy Law Colloquium, the Natural Resources Law Teachers Workshop, the Stanford Legal Research in Progress Workshop, the Poverty Law Conference at the University of Southern California, the EnviroSchmooze Workshop at Texas A&M, and the University of Virginia Climate Change Colloquium for comments on various iterations of this Article. I thank Megan King, Skyler Simpkins, Jessica Tsukiji, and the UCLA Law Review editorial team for feedback; Angela Pan for research assistance; and Cornell Law School, the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation, and the Knight-Hennessy Scholars and Emmett Interdisciplinary Program in Environment and Resources at Stanford for funding. Above all, I am grateful to the lawyers and organizers who took the time to speak with me about this project.

By LRIRE